Denials and appeals

MCAT Accommodations Denied? Reconsideration vs. Appeal and the 15-Day Rule

The short answer

If the AAMC denies or only partly approves your MCAT accommodations, you choose between two requests in the Accommodations Application System. A reconsideration adds new and substantial information you haven't provided before. An appeal asks the AAMC to review the decision again without additional documentation; you get one, and its decision is final. Both are generally reviewed within 30 days (AAMC guidelines; AAMC review cycles).

Whichever you choose, you must be approved and have a scheduling request in with Pearson VUE at least 15 days before your test date. If you aren't, you can test under standard conditions or reschedule, and rescheduling fees apply (MCAT Essentials 2027).

ReconsiderationNew and substantial information
AppealNo additional documentation needed
Review timeGenerally within 30 days
Hard stopApproved and scheduled 15 days before the exam

An AAMC decision letter that doesn't give you what you asked for can upend a study schedule built around one test date. This guide explains the two ways to ask the AAMC to look again, how to choose between them, how the timing works, and what evidence is most likely to change the outcome. For the full application process, see our MCAT accommodations page.

Start with the determination letter

A determination letter fully approves, partially approves or denies a request. Read it for two things: which accommodations were approved, and why the rest weren't. The reasons tell you whether the gap is evidence you can add (a reconsideration) or a judgment you think is wrong on the existing record (an appeal).

A letter saying your application is incomplete is different from a denial. In that case, reopen the incomplete application, upload what the letter says is missing, and resubmit; you don't need to resend documents you already provided (AAMC).

Reconsideration or appeal?

ReconsiderationAppeal
What it isA request to review the decision with new and substantial informationA request to review the decision again on the record you already submitted
What you sendInformation you haven't provided before that adds to the AAMC's understanding of your functioning, such as new test results or information from a different qualified professionalNo additional documentation is necessary
What doesn't workA follow-up letter, from you or a professional, that only repeats information you already provided—
Review timeGenerally within 30 daysGenerally within 30 days
How many—One appeal; the AAMC's decision on it is final
When to consider itThe decision identifies a gap you can address with new or clarified documentation, and the process accepts itYou can point to evidence already in the file that the decision overlooked, or explain how the reviewer misapplied the standard

AAMC allows one appeal, and its decision on that appeal is final. If you have new and substantial information, AAMC directs you to request reconsideration (AAMC guidelines).

Sources: AAMC Application Guidelines and Requirements; Submitting an Application or Request. The "When to consider it" row is our guidance, not the AAMC's. Check your decision notice and the AAMC's rules for the review options, filing deadlines, and whether you can submit new evidence. You don't need to resubmit documents you already provided, and you can't edit the history section from your initial application; add clarifications as separate documents in the Personal Statement section.

Timing: the 15-day rule decides what's possible

The AAMC generally reviews reconsiderations and appeals within 30 days. But your accommodations must be approved, and you must have a scheduling request submitted to Pearson VUE, no later than 15 days before your test date. If you don't have a decision by then, or the accommodations aren't approved, you can test under standard conditions or reschedule to a later date, and rescheduling fees apply (MCAT Essentials 2027). To schedule with accommodations, you call Pearson VUE after approval (AAMC scheduling). If you do test with accommodations, AAMC's AMCAS guidance says the MCAT scores it reports do not indicate whether you tested with accommodations (AAMC, Section 9 of the AMCAS Application; see the FAQ on our MCAT accommodations page).

AAMC's recommended dates for a January 15, 2027 examDate
Recommended submission date for an initial applicationOctober 2, 2026
Recommended submission date for a reconsideration, appeal or extensionDecember 1, 2026
Approved, with a scheduling request submitted to Pearson VUE (15 days before)December 31, 2026

Source: AAMC Review Cycles and Important Dates, which lists every 2027 test date. In the AAMC's table, the reconsideration and appeal date falls 45 days before the exam, which leaves the 30-day review plus the 15-day scheduling window. Requests are reviewed in the order received and can't be expedited. You can file after the recommended date, but the 15-day deadline still applies.

Questions about your own request?

We'll review your exam, documents and deadline with you in a free consultation.

What counts as new and substantial information

The AAMC says new information should add to its understanding of your functioning, and gives new test results and information from a different qualified professional as examples. It suggests consulting your evaluator or another qualified professional to identify what to submit (AAMC guidelines). In practice, match each new document to a reason in the letter:

  • If the letter questions whether you're limited compared with most people, look for objective data the AAMC hasn't seen, such as timed and untimed test scores or prior evaluations.
  • If it says the request isn't supported by your history, add verification of past accommodations (an IEP, 504 plan, disability services letter or another testing agency's approval) listing what you received and when.
  • If it points to old documentation, check the AAMC's recency rules for your condition before you book a new evaluation.
  • If the evaluator's report didn't explain why you need a specific accommodation, ask for a report or letter that does, with new analysis rather than a restatement.
  • Use the Personal Statement section for a short explanation of what's new and which concern each document answers.

For documentation rules by condition, see our MCAT accommodations page; the AAMC's Application Guidelines and Requirements also set how recent an evaluation must be for each condition.

A note on the AAMC's financial help for evaluations

If you've been approved for AAMC's Fee Assistance Program and have an outdated comprehensive evaluation, you can apply for up to $1,000 toward a re-evaluation. Apply through Service Requests in the Accommodation Application System and wait for approval before getting evaluated. AAMC excludes first-time and already-completed evaluations and says the benefit is not intended to fund a new evaluation for re-review of a prior accommodations decision (AAMC Accommodations Financial Benefit).

What the ADA requires of the AAMC

Under the ADA's testing regulation, the AAMC must offer the MCAT in a way that best ensures your results reflect your aptitude or achievement rather than your disability. Documentation requests must be reasonable and limited to the need for the accommodation, the AAMC must give considerable weight to accommodations you received in similar testing situations or under an IEP or 504 plan, and it must respond in a timely manner (28 C.F.R. ยง 36.309). The Justice Department's guidance adds that a history of academic success doesn't by itself mean you don't have a disability (DOJ, Testing Accommodations). For how these rules have played out with other testing organizations, see our guides to USMLE and LSAT denials.

Before you file: a short checklist

  • List every reason in the determination letter, word for word.
  • Count back from your test date: you need a decision and a Pearson VUE scheduling request 15 days before it.
  • Decide whether you have new and substantial information (reconsideration) or want a review of the existing record (appeal).
  • Ask your evaluator about new data or analysis, not a letter that repeats the report.
  • If the timing won't work, compare testing under standard conditions with rescheduling, including the fee.

If you'd like help deciding, see what to do after a denial or contact us for a free consultation.

Common questions

What's the difference between an MCAT reconsideration and an appeal?

A reconsideration adds new and substantial information you haven't provided before. An appeal asks the AAMC to review its decision again without additional documentation. AAMC allows one appeal, and its decision on that appeal is final. Both are submitted in the Accommodations Application System.

How long does an MCAT reconsideration or appeal take?

The AAMC generally reviews reconsiderations, appeals and extensions within 30 days. Requests are reviewed in the order received and can't be expedited.

What if I don't get a decision before my MCAT?

You must be approved and have a scheduling request submitted to Pearson VUE at least 15 days before your test date. If not, you can test under standard conditions or reschedule, and rescheduling fees apply.

Is a new letter from my doctor enough for a reconsideration?

Only if it adds something new. The AAMC says a follow-up letter that only conveys previously provided information is insufficient. New test results or information from a different qualified professional are examples of what it looks for.

Do I need to resend my original documents?

No. The AAMC says you don't need to resubmit documentation you already provided. Upload only new or updated materials, and add any clarification as a separate document in the Personal Statement section.

What if my application was marked incomplete rather than denied?

Reopen the incomplete application, upload what the determination letter says is missing, and resubmit. That's different from a reconsideration or appeal.

When should I submit a reconsideration or appeal?

By the AAMC's recommended date for your test date, which in its 2027 table falls 45 days before the exam. For a January 15, 2027 exam, that's December 1, 2026.

Talk it through before you file

Tell us which exam you are taking, your test date and where things stand. The first consultation is free, and we will tell you honestly whether we think we can help.