The short answer
If NBME denies or only partly approves your USMLE accommodations, you can ask it to reconsider, once per registration, through the MyUSMLE Portal. You must file while your eligibility period is still open and before you test. NBME considers only new, substantive evidence it hasn't already reviewed, and a reconsideration can take about 60 business days (USMLE; USMLE process video).
So the two questions that matter most are: what evidence would answer the reasons in your decision letter, and is there enough time left in your eligibility period for NBME to review it?
A denial from NBME usually arrives when you're deep in dedicated study, with a school deadline or a residency timeline behind it. This guide explains what your options are, how much time each one takes, what NBME means by "new and substantive" evidence, and what the ADA requires of NBME. For the full request process, see our USMLE accommodations page, and for first-time Step 1 requests, our guide to Step 1 accommodations.
First, read what the decision letter actually decided
NBME emails a decision letter and releases the hold on your scheduling permit. Not every letter is a flat denial. USMLE says accommodations can be approved in full or in part, for example less additional testing time than you asked for, or additional break time instead of additional testing time. It denies accommodations when it finds the documentation doesn't support the need (USMLE common questions). If USMLE approved only part of your request, compare the decision with what you asked for so you can identify which accommodations are still at issue.
Before you decide anything, write down each reason the letter gives. Those reasons are the outline of any reconsideration. If a reason is unclear, you can write to the reviewer; NBME says you'll typically get a response within about two business days. NBME won't discuss your file with your doctor or psychologist directly, so questions from your provider should go through you (USMLE common questions).
Your options after a USMLE denial
| Option | How it works | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Request reconsideration | One per active registration, in the MyUSMLE Portal, with new and substantive evidence | Must be filed before you test and while your eligibility period is open; about 60 business days |
| Ask the reviewer a question first | Write to your reviewer about the decision; NBME says you'll typically get an answer in about two business days | NBME doesn't take calls about the file or speak with your providers |
| Accept a partial approval and test | Schedule with the accommodations NBME approved | Once you test, you can no longer seek reconsideration for that registration |
| Withdraw a pending request and test under standard conditions | Withdrawing a pending request releases the hold on your scheduling permit | Every attempt counts toward USMLE's limit of four attempts per Step |
| Request again on a later Step | A New Request with documentation NBME hasn't reviewed | About 60 business days; plan it into your next registration |
Sources: USMLE Test Accommodations; USMLE common questions.
How NBME reconsideration works
You may request one reconsideration per active registration. For Step 1, for example, that means one reconsideration as long as you haven't tested and your scheduling permit hasn't expired. You file it in the MyUSMLE Portal: open the Test Accommodations tab, choose Actions, then Request Reconsideration (USMLE Test Accommodations).
USMLE's process video says decisions on reconsideration requests, like new requests, can take approximately 60 business days (USMLE process video transcript). That's roughly three calendar months, and it competes with a three-month eligibility period.
Timing: the reconsideration has to fit your eligibility period
Your eligibility period is a three-month window. USMLE asks that a request be submitted with at least 60 days left in that window; if fewer remain, you must update your eligibility period so there's time to review it. After your scheduling permit is issued, you can request one contiguous three-month extension, for a fee, within 25 days after your original window ends (USMLE common questions). If your eligibility period starts while a request is still being processed, USMLE tells you to contact your Disability Services Specialist about whether you can still test in time.
| Illustrative example (our arithmetic, no holidays): June 1–August 31, 2027 eligibility period | Date |
|---|---|
| Initial request complete and exam registration confirmed (USMLE's suggested "early March") | Monday, March 1 |
| About 60 business days later: initial decision | Around Monday, May 24 |
| Reconsideration submitted, once the eligibility window opens | Tuesday, June 1 |
| About 60 business days later: reconsideration decision | Around Tuesday, August 24 |
| Eligibility period ends | Tuesday, August 31 |
The dates are our own arithmetic, counting 60 weekdays after each starting date. The 60-business-day estimate comes from USMLE's process video; actual review times vary, holidays add days, and the clock starts only when your file is complete. Even on this schedule, an August 24 decision leaves only about a week before the window closes, although the request was filed on USMLE's recommended schedule. If your window is getting short, write to your Disability Services Specialist about your eligibility period before you file.
Questions about your own request?
We'll review your exam, documents and deadline with you in a free consultation.
What counts as new and substantive evidence
NBME says to send new and substantive documentation or information it hasn't already reviewed, and not to re-send what you already submitted. Letters from you or a professional that only repeat information you already provided are generally not enough. NBME also says it doesn't ask you to undergo any new or redundant evaluation, assessment or testing to seek reconsideration (USMLE Test Accommodations).
In practice, "new" usually means records that fill the gap the letter identified. USMLE's guidelines list the kinds of evidence it looks for (USMLE guidelines):
- A personal statement covering the history of your impairment, your current functional limitations, and why you need each accommodation now, especially if you haven't used it before.
- A treating or evaluating professional's report showing how diagnostic criteria are currently met, your current limitations in daily life and under standard testing conditions, and a rationale for each accommodation.
- For ADHD, a rationale for why additional testing time is needed rather than additional break time or a separate testing area.
- For a psychiatric condition, documentation completed within the past six months.
- Objective records of functioning: report cards, transcripts, teacher or supervisor feedback, performance evaluations, standardized test score reports and prior evaluations.
- Official records of past accommodations from schools or other testing entities (including a 504 plan or IEP), listing what was approved and when, plus your medical school's Certification of Test Accommodations (CPTA) form if it applies.
Match each new document to a reason in the letter. If the letter says your documentation doesn't show a current limitation compared with most people, an updated report that addresses that comparison does more than another summary of your history. If the letter says there's no record of the accommodation, school or employment records showing how you've managed timed work may matter more than a new diagnosis. A one-page table that lists each reason, the new exhibit that answers it and where to find it helps a reviewer see what changed. Our guide to accommodation appeal letters shows that format.
What the ADA requires of NBME
NBME is a private testing entity, so the ADA's testing rule applies directly. It must offer the exam in a way that best ensures your results reflect your aptitude or achievement rather than your disability. Any documentation it requires must be reasonable and limited to the need for the accommodation requested. It must give considerable weight to documentation of past accommodations in similar testing situations, including under an IEP or 504 plan, and it must respond in a timely manner (28 C.F.R. ยง 36.309). The Justice Department's guidance adds that a history of academic success doesn't by itself mean you don't have a disability, and that reports from professionals who have personally evaluated you should generally carry more weight than reviewers who haven't (DOJ, Testing Accommodations).
What enforcement and court cases show
These are examples of how disputes with NBME have gone, not predictions about any one case. The first is a settlement; the other three are preliminary-injunction rulings, made early in a lawsuit under a strict test for emergency relief.
- 2011 Justice Department settlement. NBME agreed to provide accommodations to a Yale medical student with dyslexia, double testing time and a separate testing area, as part of a settlement with the Justice Department, after twice refusing his requests (DOJ).
- Ramsay v. NBME (3d Cir. 2020). The Third Circuit affirmed a preliminary injunction requiring NBME to provide testing accommodations, double time, to a medical student with dyslexia and ADHD. It upheld the district court's decision to give more weight to the professionals who evaluated her than to NBME's reviewers, and agreed that NBME had placed too much weight on her academic success (opinion).
- Doherty v. NBME (5th Cir. 2019). In an unpublished opinion, the Fifth Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction for 50% extra time on Step 2 CK because the evidence in that record did not adequately compare her limitations with those of the general population. The court left open the precise scope of that comparison group (opinion).
- Sampson v. NBME (E.D.N.Y. 2022; 2d Cir. 2023). The district court granted a preliminary injunction ordering double time, a separate room and extended breaks on Step 1. The Second Circuit vacated it because the injunction alone would not prevent the claimed harm: the medical school's separate graduation policy could still prevent him from continuing (district court; Second Circuit).
The lesson for a reconsideration is practical: the strongest files show a current limitation compared with most people, explain why each accommodation addresses it, and give NBME's reviewers objective records they can't easily discount. If you're considering a complaint to the Justice Department (civilrights.justice.gov) or a lawsuit, get legal advice early, because emergency relief has to move quickly.
Before you decide: a short checklist
- List every reason in the decision letter, word for word.
- Check how many days are left in your eligibility period, and whether you've already tested or let your permit expire.
- Ask your evaluator or treating professional to address each reason directly, without repeating what NBME already has.
- Gather objective records NBME hasn't seen: transcripts, score reports, accommodation records, evaluations and feedback.
- If time is short, write to your Disability Services Specialist about your eligibility period before you file.
- Ask your medical school how its own deadlines for passing the Step interact with your timeline.
If you'd like a second set of eyes before you file, see what to do after a denial or contact us for a free consultation.
Common questions
Can I appeal a USMLE accommodations denial?
Yes, through a request for reconsideration in the MyUSMLE Portal. You get one per active registration, and you must file before you test and while your eligibility period is open.
How long does USMLE reconsideration take?
USMLE says decisions on reconsideration requests can take approximately 60 business days, the same as new requests. That's roughly three calendar months.
What should I send with a USMLE reconsideration request?
New and substantive evidence NBME hasn't already reviewed, matched to the reasons in your decision letter. Letters that only repeat information you already provided are generally not enough, and you shouldn't re-send earlier documents.
Do I need a new evaluation to ask NBME to reconsider?
NBME says it doesn't ask you to undergo any new or redundant evaluation, assessment or testing to seek reconsideration. If your original documentation wasn't comprehensive or current, it recommends providing or supplementing it.
Can I take the USMLE while my reconsideration is pending?
Ask Disability Services before you schedule. Once you test, you can no longer request reconsideration for that registration, and every attempt counts toward USMLE's limit of four attempts per Step.
What if my eligibility period is running out?
Write to your Disability Services Specialist. USMLE asks for at least 60 days left in your window when you submit a request, and allows one three-month extension, for a fee, within 25 days after your original window ends.
Will a partial approval show on my score report?
No. USMLE score reports and transcripts don't note test accommodations.