The short answer
If NBOME denies or only partly approves your COMLEX-USA accommodations, you can ask it to reconsider, once per examination level, in writing to testacc@nbome.org. NBOME considers a reconsideration only if you send new and compelling documentation or information it hasn't already reviewed, with a written rationale explaining why its decision was wrong (NBOME instructions; Bulletin of Information).
Reconsideration gets the same level of review as a first request and can take about 75 days. And if you take the exam before NBOME decides, your request is treated as withdrawn and your standard score counts. So the two questions that matter most are: what new evidence answers NBOME's concerns, and does your school's testing timeline leave room for another review?
A COMLEX accommodations denial tends to land when your college of osteopathic medicine expects you to sit for the exam with your class. This guide explains your options after a denial, how NBOME reconsideration works, what kind of evidence answers NBOME's concerns, and what the ADA requires of a testing organization. For how to make a first request, see the COMLEX section of our USMLE and COMLEX accommodations page.
First, read what NBOME actually decided
A decision isn't always all or nothing. NBOME can approve some accommodations and deny others, for example additional break time but not additional testing time. If NBOME approved only part of your request, compare the decision with what you asked for so you can identify which accommodations are still at issue. Then write down each concern the decision raises. Those concerns are the outline of any reconsideration, because NBOME's Bulletin describes reconsideration as a request supported by new information that addresses NBOME's concerns (Bulletin of Information).
Your options after a COMLEX denial
| Option | How it works | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Request reconsideration | One per examination level, in writing to testacc@nbome.org, with new information and a written rationale | About 75 days; don't re-send documents NBOME already has |
| Accept a partial approval and test | NBOME tells you in writing how to register and schedule the accommodated exam | Ask NBOME first whether reconsideration is still available after you test with the approved accommodations |
| Test under standard conditions | You can hold a standard seat while a request is pending | If you test before a decision, the request is withdrawn and the score is reported normally; scored attempts count toward the four-attempt limit |
| Request again for the next level | A new Request for Test Accommodations application for that level | Accommodations NBOME didn't approve before need new documentation it hasn't seen; plan for 60 to 75 days or longer |
Sources: NBOME instructions; COMLEX-USA Bulletin of Information 2026–2027; NBOME Test Accommodations.
How NBOME reconsideration works
NBOME's instructions set four rules for reconsidering a denied request (NBOME instructions):
- You must submit new and compelling documentation or information that NBOME hasn't already received and reviewed.
- You must include a written rationale explaining why you believe NBOME's decision was incorrect and why the application should be reconsidered.
- Don't re-send documentation you submitted before.
- You get one reconsideration per examination level of COMLEX-USA, submitted in writing. The Bulletin says to email it to testacc@nbome.org.
The Bulletin says reconsideration requests receive the same level of review as initial applications and are typically decided within approximately 75 days of receipt; the instructions say up to 60 to 75 days (Bulletin of Information; NBOME instructions). NBOME asks you to follow up if you don't receive a confirmation of receipt within five business days, and its email system won't accept messages over 150 MB, so split large files (NBOME).
Neither document sets a deadline for asking NBOME to reconsider. The practical deadline is your exam date. If you take the exam before NBOME decides, NBOME treats your application as withdrawn and scores and reports your standard exam normally (Bulletin of Information).
Timing: fit the review into your school's schedule
NBOME recommends submitting accommodation requests at least 90 days before the first day of your preferred testing window (NBOME), and suggests scheduling an exam at least 120 days ahead because seats are limited (Bulletin of Information). You may hold a standard seat while a request is pending. If accommodations are approved before you test, you'll need to cancel that seat and schedule an accommodated exam, and cancellations within 30 days of the exam date carry a fee unless NBOME waives it (Bulletin; instructions).
| Illustrative example (our arithmetic, calendar days) | Date |
|---|---|
| Complete application received by NBOME | Monday, January 4, 2027 |
| About 75 days later: initial decision | Around Saturday, March 20 |
| Reconsideration submitted with new documentation | Monday, March 29 |
| About 75 days later: reconsideration decision | Around Saturday, June 12 |
The dates are our own arithmetic, counting 75 calendar days from each starting date. NBOME's Bulletin says decisions generally come within approximately 75 days of receipt, and its instructions say 60 to 75 days, or as many as 90 during peak periods. The clock runs from a complete file; if NBOME tells you something is missing, you have 30 days to supply it or the request is closed. In this example, the whole process takes more than five months, so compare it with your school's deadline for passing Level 1 or Level 2-CE before you decide.
Questions about your own request?
We'll review your exam, documents and deadline with you in a free consultation.
What counts as new and compelling evidence
NBOME's instructions list what a complete request should contain. A reconsideration works best when it fills the specific gaps in that list that NBOME's decision identified (NBOME instructions):
- A full evaluation from a qualified professional that states the diagnosis, identifies each major life activity limited, and explains how the impairment substantially limits it compared with most people in the general population.
- A recent assessment: NBOME asks that the most recent one be no more than about three years before the request, and no more than one year for psychiatric conditions such as anxiety or depressive disorders.
- The names of all diagnostic tests, the dates, and specific results in standard scores, from reliable, valid tests with age-based norms, with an interpretation that supports the diagnosis.
- A rationale for each accommodation: why it's necessary for the exam to be accessible, without changing what the exam measures.
- A detailed history of treatment and medication, and whether it relieves the impairment.
- Historical educational and developmental records, such as report cards and transcripts, and score reports from all standardized exams you've taken, with and without accommodations (SAT, ACT, MCAT, GRE).
- If you had accommodations in medical school, the Verification of Test Accommodations completed by your dean or the dean's representative.
- The evaluator's CV or other documentation of their qualifications.
Match each new document to a concern in the decision. If NBOME questioned whether your limitation is substantial compared with most people, an updated evaluation that addresses that comparison does more than another summary of your history. If NBOME found the documentation out of date, a current assessment within NBOME's recency guidance answers it directly. A one-page table listing each concern, the new exhibit that answers it and where to find it helps a reviewer see what changed. Our guide to accommodation appeal letters shows that format.
If you asked for extra time
NBOME says COMLEX-USA measures "knowledge fluency," the ability to recall, interpret and apply clinical knowledge without hesitation. Its instructions say it may approve extended testing time, but only to accommodate the impaired skills needed to access the exam; in NBOME's view, more time than that would fundamentally alter what the exam measures (NBOME instructions). A request for extra time should therefore explain which skill, such as reading decoding or processing speed, is impaired, how the evidence shows it, and why the amount of time requested offsets that impairment. Under federal law, NBOME must still offer the exam so the results best reflect your aptitude or achievement rather than your disability (28 C.F.R. § 36.309). An evaluator who addresses both points explains the request in terms NBOME's reviewers will recognize.
What the ADA requires of NBOME
NBOME is a private testing organization that offers licensing exams, so the ADA's testing rule applies directly. It must offer the exam in a way that best ensures your results reflect your aptitude or achievement rather than your disability. Any documentation it requires must be reasonable and limited to the need for the accommodation requested. It must give considerable weight to documentation of past accommodations in similar testing situations, including under an IEP or 504 plan, and it must respond in a timely manner (28 C.F.R. § 36.309). The ADA also says the ameliorative effects of mitigating measures, such as medication, aren't considered in deciding whether you have a disability (42 U.S.C. § 12102(4)(E)). The Justice Department's guidance adds that reports from professionals who have personally evaluated you should generally carry more weight than reports from reviewers who haven't (DOJ, Testing Accommodations).
What court cases against NBOME show
These are examples of how disputes with NBOME have gone, not predictions about any one case. In the cases we found, courts ruled for NBOME on the records before them, and the reasons are instructive.
- Healy v. NBOME (S.D. Ind. 2012). After NBOME denied a Level 1 request initially, on reconsideration and on a further appeal, the student sued. Following a bench trial, the court found he had a reading disorder but that it didn't substantially limit him compared with the general population, and that the evidence didn't establish ADHD or anxiety as an impairment under the ADA. It denied the injunction (opinion).
- Bibber v. NBOME (E.D. Pa. 2016). After a final injunction hearing, the court denied a request for 50% extra time on Level 1. It acknowledged the student's long history of accommodations, including on the PSAT and SAT, but found that her test scores placed her reading in the average range compared with the general population. In Ramsay v. NBME (2020), a USMLE case, the Third Circuit distinguished Bibber because the student there had lower scores on some of the same assessments and explained how her reading differed from the average person's (opinion).
- James v. NBOME (S.D. Ind. 2026). NBOME approved additional break time and a separate room after the student submitted more documentation, but not additional testing time; she later passed Level 1. The court granted NBOME summary judgment because damages aren't available to private parties under Title III of the ADA and, having passed, she couldn't show the ongoing or imminent harm needed for an injunction. The ruling didn't decide whether she had a disability.
The lessons for a reconsideration are practical. The files that failed didn't show, with objective scores, a limitation compared with most people. And because the ADA's testing provision allows private parties injunctive relief, not damages, timing matters: a legal challenge generally has to be made before the exam you need accommodations for. If you're considering a complaint to the Justice Department (civilrights.justice.gov) or a lawsuit, get legal advice early.
Before you decide: a short checklist
- List each concern in NBOME's decision, word for word, and note which accommodations were approved.
- Check whether you've already used your one reconsideration for this level.
- Count backward from your school's deadline: about 75 days for review, plus time to gather new documentation and schedule.
- Ask your evaluator to address each concern directly, with standard scores and a rationale for each accommodation, without repeating what NBOME already has.
- Gather records NBOME hasn't seen: transcripts, standardized test score reports, accommodation records and your dean's verification.
- Don't take the exam while a request is pending unless you've decided to test under standard conditions.
If you'd like a second set of eyes before you file, see what to do after a denial or contact us for a free consultation.
Common questions
Can I appeal a COMLEX accommodations denial?
NBOME offers reconsideration: one per COMLEX-USA examination level, requested in writing to testacc@nbome.org, with new and compelling documentation or information it hasn't already reviewed and a written rationale explaining why the decision was incorrect.
How long does NBOME reconsideration take?
NBOME's Bulletin says reconsideration requests get the same level of review as initial applications and are typically decided within approximately 75 days of receipt. Its instructions say up to 60 to 75 days.
What should I send with a COMLEX reconsideration request?
New information that addresses NBOME's concerns, such as an updated evaluation with standard scores, records NBOME hasn't seen, or your dean's verification of medical school accommodations, plus a written rationale. Don't re-send documents you already submitted.
Can I take COMLEX while my accommodations request is pending?
You can hold a standard seat while a request is pending. But if you take the exam before NBOME decides, NBOME treats your application as withdrawn and scores and reports your standard exam normally.
How recent does my evaluation need to be for COMLEX?
NBOME asks that the most recent assessment be no more than about three years before your request, and no more than one year for psychiatric conditions such as anxiety or depressive disorders.
Why does NBOME limit extra time on COMLEX?
NBOME says COMLEX-USA measures knowledge fluency, and that it approves extended time only to accommodate the impaired skills needed to access the exam. A request for extra time should explain which skill is impaired and why the amount requested offsets it.
Do I need to reapply for accommodations on Level 2-CE or Level 3?
Yes. You submit a new application for each level. If you're asking for accommodations NBOME approved before, you don't need new documentation; for anything beyond that, you need documentation NBOME hasn't seen.